top of page

Judge declines to hold Athens/Oconee County DA in contempt; vacates dismissal of child rape case

Western Judicial Circuit Chief Judge Eric Norris

By Joe Johnson

Western Judicial Circuit Chief Judge Eric Norris reportedly has denied a motion for contempt against the circuit's district attorney Deborah Gonzalez, chief prosecutor for Athens-Clarke and Oconee counties.

The contempt order had been sought by Watkinsville attorney Kevin Epps as part of a civil action he initiated in an attempt to have the court compel Gonzalez, an inexperienced criminal prosecutor, to fulfill her duties as required under Georgia law. The former entertainment lawyer's mismanagement and policies of her office has resulted in procedural errors that allowed some serious felony cases to be dismissed, Epps has claimed.

DA Deborah Gonzalez

The evidence showed that following the Court's May 25 order, DA Gonzalez produced 42 documents before the 15 day deadline," The Oconee Enterprise reported that Norris wrote in his ruling. "Based on this review, the court is satisfied that DA Gonzalez complied with the May 25 Order...Finally, given that DA Gonzalez's office had been disqualified from the case as of May 19, her failure to provide Tracker notes was not willful, given her belief that she was not ethically permitted to review the case file upon withdrawal from the case."

In his order, Norris also granted a motion to vacate a dismissal of rape, incest and child molestation charges against Athens defendant Michael Lareco Daniel, meaning that Daniel can be tried on these charges.

"Jeopardy has not attached, and the case stands in the same procedure posture as before the April 17, 2023 trial week," Norris wrote. "Prosecution in this case may be renewed."

932 views3 comments


Im appalled at the unfairness here. Who knows all is in charge. Happy Sunday! Blessings to all involved!


Izzy Mendalbaum
Izzy Mendalbaum
Jul 09, 2023

This personal vendetta is doing no one any good. The DA is surely on notice that she must do better or this type of law suit will continue. So glad the rape case will be heard. All we want is the truth.


Jul 08, 2023

This is what the voters want. They knew who she was when they voted for her.

bottom of page